Gentle Parenting

Is Gentle Parenting Effective? Read Our Story

POST UPDATED – AUGUST 2023

Toddlers can be frustrating at times, but I always try and put myself in their shoes. How much emotion would you feel if you had something to say but didn’t know the words yet? Bless them. Yes, it is tough to think like this when a toddler is testing your limits and pushing your boundaries. But as adults, I feel like we must. We are responsible adults and our brains are actually capable of processing emotions. Unlike the brain of a child.

is gentle parenting effective

Please notebefore we get into this post, I should say, I acknowledge parenting is the hardest job in the world. I get angry and frustrated, just like any other parent. But in our household, we do make a conscious effort to resolve conflict situations differently with our little ones.

I am no expert on this subject, nor do I incorporate all the elements of gentle parenting. I am still very much on a learning journey. But I wanted to share our experience in order to help other people out there.

Accepting that all behaviour is communication and it is age appropriate for their developmental stage, really allows you to parent differently.

Let’s look at the science

I think once you get your head around the fact toddlers don’t actually possess the same brain capabilities and development as adults, you can start to take things less personally. My little one is quite intelligent and can be grown up when she wants to. My hubby, mentioned the other day that sometimes we expect too much of her because of this, and we must remember the below.

Though your 3-year-old is beginning to understand the emotions they are feeling, they still have very little control over them. If they find something funny, they’ll laugh hysterically. If something makes them feel sad or angry, they’ll burst into tears.
If they feel something, they are likely to act on it. This may mean snatching a toy away from another child if they want to play with it, or getting upset when they want a snack after being told they have to wait until dinnertime. Delayed gratification means nothing to them – they want it and want it now.
Three- and 4-year-old children may use hitting, biting, or pushing as a way to solve conflicts. They simply don’t understand the difference between appropriate and inappropriate interactions yet. It’s your job to teach your child that there are right and wrong ways to express emotions and resolve problems with others.

Webmd

Changing your mindset about toddler behaviour

How powerful is reading this? Children may also laugh as a default when they don’t know what else to do. As a parent, it could seem like they are laughing at being told boundaries, or being sneaky. But this probably isn’t the case.

Accepting that all behaviour is communication and it is age appropriate for their developmental stage, really allows you to parent differently.

When you realise toddlers are simply finding their way through the world, how to respond and they simply don’t know the way yet. The adults around them can then act accordingly.

How did I realise what we did was gentle parenting?

I won’t mince my words here. Given my own upbringing, at a different stage time, where harsh discipline was accepted, I thought the term “gentle parenting” was just parents not being firm enough with their toddlers. In the very early days of having a baby, I had visions of reasoning with a little person in the supermarket and losing control. Which in turn would mean I lost control of the situation. 

Joining TikTok made me realise how we parent within our family, is actually gentle parenting. And following Kelly Medina Enos on TikTok has helped. I love how honest she is and following her journey makes me feel comfortable with what we are doing. More importantly, it will never be perfect. 

is gentle parenting effective

What changed in our parenting style?

Before our little one was born, I thought I would be a much harsher, stricter parent than I actually am.

When your little one starts moving around, touching plugs and threatening to hurt themselves every minute, you need to have parenting conversations. And you won’t always agree. My hubby and I were brought up the same way. Pretty afraid of our parents at times  – that look they would give, or raised voices indicated we should stop doing this.

But I just have a burning question to ask, do you get the best out of anyone, even adults when you raise your voice?  As I get older, I realise the answer is no.

Want to read all about our Family Days Out? If you would like your attraction or business reviewed, send me an email with your idea for a collaboration

Setting a good example 

Collectively, we decided a while ago we wanted to avoid shouting around our little one (this isn’t always possible – please don’t think we or any other parent is perfect – there are still disagreements and sometimes raised voices).

If we do shout, snap, or get frustrated, we talk about it together, with our little one. We say sorry and move on. And we have taught this lesson so effectively, our little one will come and apologise to us if she does something she knows she shouldn’t. Granted, it may take a while for her to walk away and come back. But she always comes back, eventually. And we try to mirror this example between ourselves.

I really believe this technique is teaching her to resolve conflict herself and how she should appropriately do this. Also that no human being is perfect. If she does something and apologies when she doesn’t need to, we explain that even adults get things wrong sometimes and this isn’t something she needs to apologise for.  

is gentle parenting effective

Download this infographic

I’ve written another post, all about Gentle Parenting – check it out here

Check out more tips & resources on my parenting page

Come say hello on TikTok!

Modelling behaviour 

In order to calm a tantrum, we also do a breathing technique with her and one of us will take her out of the situation to calm down. I believe toddlers get very overwhelmed by their surroundings. This in itself could cause a meltdown. Hell, as an adult sometimes I get overwhelmed.

They need help not frustration 

Just think for a second about any situation you have ever resolved by shouting. Or being confrontational, or getting frustrated. I bet it is very few. Why then, do we get frustrated with toddlers? Surely we should be actively helping them handle emotions, especially when they don’t fully understand what is happening to them. They don’t have the capability or brain power to regulate themselves and will probably wonder why adults are also becoming frustrated.

There are some other blog posts in the Gentle Parenting category – check them out here

Parents are a guide 

It’s a heavy burden to carry, but as parents, we are responsible for guiding our little ones. Whether we like it or not, how they develop now will also greatly impact their future lives. 

Why it matters

Positive experiences throughout childhood help to build healthy brains, while experiencing childhood trauma and abuse can harm a child’s brain development (Shonkoff et al, 2015).
But our brains always have the potential to change and grow. It’s never too late to give a child or young person positive brain-building experiences.

NSPCC.ORG

Final thoughts 

I was dubious about releasing this post. Simply because of my feelings when I first heard the term ‘gentle parenting’. We still have a lot to learn and our parenting style will never be perfect. But hopefully, we are setting a foundation to provide our little one with the tools she will need to thrive in life. 

Keep an eye on my parenting resources page and my TikTok to follow our gentle parenting journey. I plan to share with you any resources we are using. 

Any advice is also welcome – let us know in the comments below.

is gentle parenting effective

5 Things That Happened When We Started Gentle Parenting

My blog is all about never judging any other parent. We are not perfect. Research has proven human beings react in a certain way, to conflict. It’s an automatic process and sometimes we can’t help it! However, reacting in anger isn’t helpful in the moment. 

Our small humans need us to be emotional support. They need us to be more emotionally intelligent, so we can set a great example of how to manage our emotions.

However, I know very well, parenting is the hardest job in the world. If you follow me on TikTok you will see that I try to make light of the situation and use humour to get through the difficult days.

Gentle Parenting

Quick note: Some of the links contained on this page are affiliate links and if you go through them to make a purchase, I will earn a commission. I only recommend products I use myself and think would be useful for other people.

What is gentle parenting?

The goal of gentle parenting is to raise confident, independent and happy children through empathy, respect and understanding, and setting healthy boundaries. This parenting style focuses largely on age-appropriate development.

Cleveland clinic

Instead of focusing on punishment and reward, gentle parenting focuses on improving a child’s self-awareness and understanding of their own behavior.

Cleveland clinic

The benefits of gentle parenting

Gentle parenting, when applied correctly, can:  

  • help children develop confidence, independence, self-esteem, and strong emotion regulation skills
  • reduce power struggles between a parent and child 
  • improve relationships between family members at home
  • improve communication between parent and child

Misconceptions of gentle parenting

Some people misunderstand gentle parenting and believe it is too soft as a parenting technique. It’s important to say that as a family, we enforce boundaries. We do also use some rewards, but never punishment. Recently we’ve started adopting natural consequences instead of punishment.

Gentle parenting does not equal a lack of boundaries – quite the opposite. We explain why there are boundaries and use the lessons we’ve taught her, to enforce why we will not tolerate certain behaviour.

The reality of gentle parenting

Gentle parenting isn’t easy. It takes time to become conscious of your reactions – but seeing the results of an emotionally intelligent child is worth it.

If you’re considering implementing gentle parenting, or elements of it like we do. I wanted to let you know about some of the benefits we have experienced since implementing this parenting method.

Let’s dive into the benefits we’ve experienced

We have a very polite child

Since being a baby, we’ve taught my little one to say please and thank you.

At four years old, she now thanks me for simple tasks like getting her cereal in the morning. It’s a genuine, heartfelt thank you. Simply because she’s been shown the reason why we need to be polite.

Everything we teach her is explained in a way she is able to understand. Rather than telling her what to do, it’s a collaborative conversation. You will always hear us asking her whether she understands. And we talk more if she doesn’t.

It’s important for children to understand the consequences of their behaviour and ultimately, be able to eventually regulate emotions by themselves. I won’t be there on her first day of school, or for her first job interview – you have to think about preparing a child for life’s challenges.

Ask yourself – how do I want my children to act and cope in future life situations that could be stressful?

She talks about her feelings & is in tune with other people’s feelings

Because we talk about our emotions and we are honest about the reasons when we do argue (newsflash – all adults argue at some point & sometimes, it’s inevitably in front of children). She, therefore, understands that even adults face situations where something can anger and upset them. That this is okay. And it’s good to talk about how we are feeling when this happens.

When she is experiencing a certain emotion or challenge, we regularly empathise and explain adults also feel this way. Or relate to something we went through as a child.

She regularly comes to me and explains something is wrong. Granted, at four years old, she says things like “I have a sicky tummy” when she’s nervous about the nursery, or feeling tired. But it’s enough for me to know as a parent, that more conversation is needed.

Recent blog posts

When I was going through my mental breakdown, she was only a baby. But she knew something was wrong and would comfort me.

We now witness this kinder side when she’s in the playground and a baby is upset. She will go over to the parent and child, in a concerned manner, and wait patiently until the baby is okay. It’s really lovely to watch.

Being taught to be kind and caring has helped, but actually being shown that by everyone around her models this behaviour, is a more powerful tool.

She apologises when shes aware of doing something wrong

When a child is in the middle of a meltdown and making no sense, there is no point in having a conversation. It just will not be productive. The same applies to adults. As an adult, you would walk away from a heated conversation. Therefore, it baffles me that some parents believe anger and harsh discipline is appropriate in these situations – surely it’s just unproductive at that moment in time. No progress can be made when a human being is in fight or flight mode.

When a child is in this mode, they need love and reassurance from us. Not anger, or harsh discipline.

Read my previous blog post about gentle parenting: IS GENTLE PARENTING EFFECTIVE? READ OUR STORY

As parents, we allow the meltdown to pass. We openly tell her, we will talk when she’s calmer and let her walk away. Usually to her bedroom. Within 10 minutes she comes back to us to give a heartfelt apology. And we all talk about why the behaviour wasn’t helpful. Then we make a point of moving on, by saying “Nothing more will be said about it“. We never dwell on it. We move on.

She is independent

As part of our gentle parenting journey, we allow as many choices as we safely can for our toddler.

She is a very independent child by nature. And rather than fight a battle on menial topics, it’s easier to allow as many small choices as we can. The ones we use frequently, involve a choice of dilute juice, and breakfast options and we also allow her to choose her own snacks from the fridge.

When we go out for the day, this extends to more varied options. And when we can, she is allowed to run free and actually be a child.

The amazing thing is, that having allowed choices, she now asks me before she makes any of them. In our case, allowing choices means we get cooperation and communication in return.

Final thoughts

I hope you enjoyed reading about our experiences with gentle parenting.

Are you a gentle parent? do you have any tips for us? or do you use other parenting techniques?

I would love to hear from you in the comments below.

Gentle Parenting

Resources – if you want to get started on your gentle parenting journey:

Twinkl resources

My TikTok videos on gentle parenting:

@sammummyconqueringanxiet

#duet with @Andrew Shaw | Executive Coach #toddlertantrum Wise words! I will never judge any #parent – we are #notperfect & human beings react in a certain way, to conflict. It’s an automatic process & sometimes we can’t help it! However, this isn’t helpful in the moment. Our small humans NEED us to be an #emotional support ❤️ it takes time to become concious of your reactions – but seeing the results of an #emotionallyintelligent child is worth it! #parents #parenting #mums #mumlife #gentleparenting

♬ toddler tantrums – Andrew Shaw | Health Coach
@sammummyconqueringanxiet

#duet with @Aldiebear amazing #parents for sitting & talking about #feelings This little one clearly has #emotionalintelligence as a result of #greatparenting It’s heartwarming to watch & reminds me we are doing exactly the right thing with #gentleparenting ❤️ #parents #parenting #fyp #viral @Sam | Mummy Conquering Anxiety

♬ Chopin Nocturne No. 2 Piano Mono – moshimo sound design
@sammummyconqueringanxiet

#duet with @Trenena Stanley #hindsight is a wonderful thing. & there is no time machine. But thank you so much for this message! #gentleparenting is the choice for us, simply because I am dealing with a #toddler who doesn’t yet have the brain capacity to #regulate her #emotions ❤️ therefore, surely, the only #instinct should be to #guide her through life’s challenges #gently #kindly & #withlove #fyp #viral

♬ original sound – Trenena Stanley
@sammummyconqueringanxiet

#duet with @Rubio Fuerte as a #workingmum I know it’s difficult. & the #mumguilt is real! But #toddlers just want our #love and to be #bondedtogether ❤️ #fyp #viral

♬ Originalton – Rubio Fuerte